Frozen Old Fashioned

Beat the summer heat with an innovative twist on a timeless classic! This Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie transforms your favorite bourbon drink into an irresistible, frosty delight. Imagine the rich notes of bourbon, the aromatic complexity of bitters, and the bright zest of orange, all blended with ice to create a refreshing slushie that’s perfect for any happy hour or summer gathering. Crowned with a juicy cherry, this “giggle juice” is designed to cool you down and lift your spirits!

Refreshing Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie with Bourbon, Bitters, and Orange Garnish

Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie: A Nostalgic Sip for Modern Summers

In a world constantly rushing forward, sometimes it’s the simple, nostalgic pleasures that truly hit the spot. Do you remember the days of genuine, old-fashioned prank calls? Not the digital, app-driven ones, but the true art form of picking up a wall-mounted phone, carefully dialing each of the seven digits, listening to the rhythmic ring, and then – *action!* My personal favorite script involved impersonating a very concerned Sears maintenance person. “Ma’am, this is Glenda from Sears. We’re doing a follow-up on your refrigerator. Is your fridge running?” “Well, yes,” the unsuspecting homeowner would often reply. “Then you’d better go catch it!” *CLICK.* The sheer delight of that simple, innocent prank was unparalleled. A moment of pure, unadulterated hilarity before the age of caller ID and instant digital connection. Oh, to have been cast on SNL then!

It’s safe to assume, with the ubiquitous presence of smartphones and their endless capabilities, that the golden age of the prank call has largely faded. Or perhaps there’s a clandestine prank call app that’s entirely escaped my notice? If so, consider this an open invitation to share your secrets!

Close-up of a frosty Old Fashioned Slushie garnished with orange slice and cherry, perfect for summer

Embracing Nostalgia in a Digital World

While I certainly appreciate the convenience and power of my smartphone, there are moments when I genuinely long for the simplicity of yesteryear. Just the other day, I was re-watching “Bill & Ted’s Excellent Adventure” and paused in amusement when they resorted to a payphone to contact their parents. The very concept of needing a quarter to make a call seems almost archaic now! While the occasional scramble for change could be frustrating, there was a certain charm in the uncertainty. Would someone be home? Would the call even connect? That element of the unknown felt more authentic, more human, than today’s instant communication. I suppose I’m revealing my age, aren’t I?

If you’re finding yourself swept up in a wave of nostalgia, perhaps even contemplating a revival of the classic prank call, I have just the liquid courage to inspire your endeavors: an Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie. At this very moment, the classic Old Fashioned is my absolute obsession. I’m captivated by its depth, its timeless elegance. But with the summer mercury soaring to what feels like 4,298 degrees Fahrenheit, I need this beloved drink to stay perfectly chilled for much longer than usual. Enter the ingenious solution: the Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie.

Ingredients for an Old Fashioned Slushie including bourbon, bitters, oranges, and ice

The Perfect Summer Spin on a Classic

I genuinely wish this idea had occurred to me sooner! Last year, I concocted a truly phenomenal Orange Mimosa Slushie that’s making a massive comeback for al fresco brunches and sunny gatherings. It frankly surprises me that major chains like Sonic haven’t hopped aboard the boozy happy hour slushie trend yet! This frosty rendition includes all the familiar, beloved elements of a traditional Old Fashioned: premium bourbon, a dash of aromatic bitters, the vibrant essence of orange, and a sweet cherry on top. The only significant additions are crushed ice, a quick blend, and then, pure, unadulterated slurping satisfaction.

This isn’t merely a drink; it’s an experience. It’s the comforting familiarity of a classic cocktail merged with the exhilarating chill of a summer treat. It’s perfect for those sweltering afternoons when a neat whiskey simply won’t do, offering a prolonged, cooling sensation that lets you savor every moment. Whether you’re unwinding on the patio, hosting a backyard barbecue, or simply dreaming of simpler times, this Old Fashioned Slushie delivers a delightful blend of sophistication and fun. It’s a testament to how even the most established traditions can be reimagined for modern enjoyment, without losing their inherent charm.

As you enjoy this icy concoction, perhaps you’ll find yourself transported back to a time of rotary phones and shared laughter. You might even hear, in the distance, a faint dial tone, followed by a familiar voice… “Hello, this is Glenda…”

Two glasses of Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie on a rustic table, ready for summer enjoyment

Finished Old Fashioned Slushie with orange and cherry garnish

Print Recipe

Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie

Yield: Makes one refreshing drink

Prep Time: 5 minutes

Cook Time: 0 minutes

Ingredients:

  • 1 generous shot (approx. 1.5-2 oz) good quality bourbon
  • 1 cup ice, preferably crushed or small cubes for easier blending
  • 4 half-moon blood orange slices, with the skin removed
  • 1 tablespoon Angostura bitters (or your preferred aromatic bitters)
  • 1 tablespoon fresh orange juice
  • Orange slice or peel, for garnish
  • Maraschino or Luxardo cherry, for garnish

Directions:

  1. In a sturdy food processor or high-speed blender, combine the bourbon, ice, deskinning blood orange slices, bitters, and fresh orange juice.
  2. Pulse the mixture repeatedly until it achieves a smooth, slushie-like consistency. If the mixture is too thick, add a tiny splash more orange juice. For a thicker consistency, add a few more ice cubes.
  3. Carefully pour the vibrant slushie mixture into a chilled glass.
  4. Garnish generously with a fresh orange slice or an elegant orange peel twist, and a perfectly ripe cherry. Serve immediately and enjoy the frosty delight!

All images and text ©Lauren Grier for The Curious Plate

Tips for Crafting the Ultimate Frozen Old Fashioned

Achieving the perfect Old Fashioned Slushie is both simple and rewarding. Here are a few tips to elevate your experience:

  • Bourbon Choice: While any good bourbon will work, a higher-proof bourbon can stand up better to the dilution from the ice, ensuring the flavor remains robust. Experiment with different brands to find your favorite profile.
  • Ice Matters: Using smaller ice cubes or pre-crushed ice will make blending significantly easier and result in a smoother, more consistent slushie texture.
  • Bitters Exploration: Angostura is classic, but don’t shy away from experimenting with other bitters. Orange bitters can enhance the citrus notes, while a touch of chocolate bitters could add a surprising depth.
  • Sweetness Adjustment: If your oranges aren’t particularly sweet, or if you prefer a slightly sweeter drink, a tiny drizzle of simple syrup (1:1 sugar to water ratio) can be added to the blender.
  • Chilled Glassware: For the longest-lasting frosty experience, chill your serving glass in the freezer for about 15-20 minutes before pouring in your slushie.
  • Garnish with Flair: A high-quality maraschino cherry (like Luxardo) makes a big difference. For an extra aromatic touch, express the oils from an orange peel over the drink before dropping it in as a garnish.

Stylized overhead shot of an Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie, emphasizing its refreshing appeal

Perfect Occasions for Your Frosty Bourbon Treat

This Frozen Old Fashioned is incredibly versatile, making it suitable for a myriad of summer scenarios:

  • Backyard BBQs and Pool Parties: An ideal thirst-quencher for outdoor entertaining, keeping guests cool and conversations flowing.
  • Happy Hour at Home: Elevate your evening unwind with a sophisticated yet fun cocktail.
  • Sunset Sips: There’s nothing quite like watching the sunset with a perfectly chilled, flavorful drink in hand.
  • “Just Because” Moments: Sometimes, the best occasion is simply the desire for a delightful, refreshing treat.

As we reach the bottom of the glass, we hope this Old Fashioned Cocktail Slushie has added a cool, timeless touch to your summer moments. It’s more than just a drink; it’s a bridge between cherished memories and new, refreshing experiences. Embrace the simplicity of a bygone era and the vibrant energy of today, all in one delightful sip. Stay tuned for more nostalgic sips and creative cocktails that promise to inspire and delight. Cheers to great times and even greater drinks!